- Guest Commentary: Earth Day or April Fools Day?
- State Roundup: Concerns raised about proposed change in DUI pot standard
- Bill would decrease pot penalties; small amounts would draw only ticket, fine
- Senate votes to restore human service cuts; bill moves to House for consideration
- Bill to restrict red light cameras passes House
- State Roundup: Budget fix in current FY not yet done
- State Roundup: GOMB Director won’t support borrowing
- Economists: pros, cons to raising the state fuel tax
- ‘Hogs fall just shy of Midwest title
- Fork and Stein Urban Gourmet delivers beer infused delicacies to Rockford
Mea (Nos?) culpa et redemptio, (Matthew 7:1-5)
Mea (Nos?) culpa et redemptio, (Matthew 7:1-5)
By Dr. Robert R. Kopp
Ive been thinking about updating Why the Old Denominations Are Going to Hell (Monday Morning, 7 March 1994) to Why the Old Denominations Have Gone to Hell.
These days, although statistics show their memberships spiraling downward, anyone who suggests the old denominations are nothing more than holding tanks for pulpiteers and pewsitters longing for the good old days is either ignorant or arrogant.
Previously, I said the decline of mainline denominations can be attributed to unconverted clergy, unconvinced laity, and pharisaical reincarnations substituting organizational order for biblical authority.
Before restating the obvious, a few confessions are compelling.
First, acknowledging my culpabilities within a Davidic and Pauline context (e.g., Psalm 51; Romans 3:23; 12:3; 1 Timothy 1:12-17; cf. Proverbs 28:13), I am sorry for past sins that compromised the integrity of my witness. While I rejoice in personal redemption of biblical proportions (see John 3; Acts 9), I comprehend if not appreciate those who try to discredit what I say by referring to whom I was.
Though I claim Christianitys redemptive ethic for myselfIt doesnt matter where youre coming from; all that matters is where youre going! (Brian Tracy)I am mournfully aware (Matthew 5:4) of not being as good as Mom had hoped. I may not be as bad as antagonists advertise, but I have not been as good as pretended.
Hence, I preferred to remain silent since being born anothen. Yet I cannot exorcise past personal hypocrisies by ignoring current corporate hypocrisies (disconnects between creeds and deeds).
Second, if Robert Frost had a lovers quarrel with the world, mine is a lovers quarrel with the mainline church. Or as Frederick Buechner explained in Wishful Thinking (1973), A prophets quarrel with the world is deep-down a lovers quarrel. If they didnt love the world, they probably wouldnt bother to tell it that its going to hell. Theyd just let it go.
I was introduced to Jesus by mainline members, Sunday School teachers, pastors, and seminaries. While I owe my soul to Jesus, Hes had a lot of help from mainliners; and, therefore, I feel a profound sense of indebtedness to them.
Finally, our Lords high priestly prayer that they may all be one…so that the world may believe that you have sent me (John 17) evokes ecumenical passion and parochial shame. Does anyone really believe Jesus lived, died, rose, and reigns to enable ecclesiastical ghettos?
I am convinced divisions in Christendom discourage a desperate world from looking to churches to inspire global reconciliation. Does a fragmented family of faith have any credibility to tell the world how to get along?
Navel-gazing institutional survival schemes along with color, class, and culture bigotries have blunted our Lords intent for a truly inclusive church enabled by the common confession of His saving Lordship in Jesus.
Fortunately, the recent movement of mainliners from museums of spirituality to mausoleums of theological uncertainty at best or duplicity at worst makes little difference to the advancement of the Kingdom. As Jesus assured, I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it (Matthew 16:18).
Unfortunately, aside from the rapidly continuing shrinkage of membership rolls, updating 1994s etiological essay is unnecessary.
My franchise, for example, has lost 1.76 million members since 1965 (PCUSA); though in amusing irony, more bureaucratic and paradenominational booths pop up in the exhibition halls of our annual meetings as the membership plummets.
Many observers assert a connection between decline and the dissipation of core confessions: (1) Jesus is Lord and Savior; (2) The Bible is Gods revealed rule for discipleship; and (3) Depending upon Gods grace, we are called to holiness as exemplified in Jesus and explained in the Bible.
Denominational renewal is envisioned as plausible with a clear, consistent, courageous, enthusiastic, and unequivocal commitment to such confessions.
Or as an older elder said to me many years ago, Watch the birds! They go where there is food!
Of course, you cant give away what you aint got for yourself.
Unconverted clergy or women and men without faith infect every level of church life. They are easy to identify. Talking about Jesus by name is onerous for them. If you arent sure about this, approach a suspect and ask her or him to say a few words about personal faith in Jesus. Ask for commentary on Romans 10:9. I have never experienced anyone who believes in Jesus who isnt psyched to talk about Him.
Unconvinced laity are products of unconverted clergy. Its the old shepherds dont follow sheep axiom. Sadly, to borrow a line from Margaret Thatcher, Standing in the middle of the road is very dangerous; you get knocked down by traffic from both sides. Obviously, mainline laity are sheep without shepherds (Isaiah 53:6). With undershepherds (clergy) misunderstanding the Good Shepherd (Jesus) through confessional confusion, sheep (members) are like two mainliners at fellowship hour. One says, I dont know who I am or where Im going. The other says, Dont worry about! Our pastor is going through the same thing! Getting back to the real issue, John Eldredge identifies the problem and provides the solution in one sentence: Healing never happens outside of intimacy with Christ (Wild at Heart, 2001).
Pharisaical reincarnations substituting organizational order for biblical authority explains how mainliners can violate biblical ethics on everything from the sanctity of all human life to human sexuality so blithely. Assuming the Bible is not bigger than their favorite parts, they embrace an ethical relativism which enslaves all issues of faith and morality to the most recent popular vote. Apostasy is acceptable as long as parliamentary procedure is used. No wonder missionary and seminary professor Samuel Moffett bellowed at the Presbyterian Congress on Renewal in Dallas, Texas (January 1985), Ive had decency and order up to here! But wheres the power?…Wheres the power to propel us across the world?…Some of the most creative and effective periods in the Church were those periods when the Gospel was hot and not respectable.
Time is running out for mainliners.
Heres why: I have this against you, that you have abandoned the love you had at first. Remember…from where you have fallen; repent, and do the works you did at first. If not, I will come to you and remove your lampstand (Revelation 2:1-7).
Many observers believe the lampstand has been removed already from mainliners.
In a letter addressing the unspoken reality for all mainline denominations, a lawyer (former pastor) wrote, Is the PCUSA simply old wineskins that must be abandoned? Or is there a sense of corporate forgiveness and redemption for past sins? Its one or the other. It cannot be both. If its a wineskins problem, dont waste your time trying to reform. Get out! But if God truly is redemptive and forgiving, He can give these gifts to the organization.
Im not sure.
If our lampstand or efficacious place in the Kingdom hasnt been removed, its flickering, fading, and failing.
But just as I have experienced the joy of redemption in Jesus through confession and repentance, I believe the same is possible for mainliners.
Thats why Im not giving up on them.
The Christophers are right: It is better to light a candle than curse the darkness (see John 3:17-21).
Personally and corporately, Ill also keep shaking salt; or as Georges Bernanos explained the prophetic: Salt stings on an open wound, but saves you from gangrene (The Diary of a Country Priest, 1937).
This is the kairos moment for mainliners.
Turn back. Or turn over.
Dr. Robert Kopp is the pastor of Bethany Presbyterian Church, Loves Park.