Rockton police chief fired, again
By Shellie Berg
By Shellie Berg
Editors note: Next week, The Rock River Times will present a story on the meeting held Tuesday night at Rockton Village Hall, where trustees announced whether they reinstated Rocktons police chief or upheld the village presidents decision.
Rockton Village President David Dwyer announced his third termination of Police Chief Richard Meacham Jan. 3 after a breathalyzer test showed Meachams blood/alcohol level between .02 and .03 percent. The legal limit is .08
Two officers conducted the test after they smelled alcohol on Meachams breath Tuesday at a meeting. The meeting started at 6 p.m., and the test was taken at 9 p.m.
At village hall the night of the firing, an emotional Dwyer took his usual board seat and announced he fired Meacham because the chief was in uniform, carrying a weapon and driving a patrol car.
In addition, Dwyer said he fired Meacham for dishonesty. He initially lied about having had any alcohol, Dwyer said. Dwyer stated that before taking the test, Meacham said he hadnt had alcohol; afterward, Meacham acknowledged he did, in fact, drink wine at dinner before the meeting.
A police officers duty is to protect the public, Dwyer said. He stated that at any time, an officer can be thrown into a life-or-death situation.
Meacham wanted to give himself a one-day
Continued on page 10
From page 1
suspension without pay, but Dwyer deemed that punishment unacceptable, Dwyer said.
Dwyer said if the board reinstates Meacham, theyre going to have a lot to explain to the public. Four of the six members must reinstate Meacham.
Before Tuesday night, trustees Anna Mae Bean, Scott Fridly and Dan Branecki hadnt made a decision as to whether they would uphold Meachams decision. Bean wouldnt comment until the meeting. Fridly and Branecki were unavialable for comment.
Reportedly,three trustees said they would reinstate MeachamScott Wallace, Lester Peterson and Dale Adams. Wallace declined to comment. Peterson couldnt be reached.
I think it was a terrible mistake that Chief Meacham made, first of all, Adams said. On the other hand, he didnt break any laws. He wasnt inebriated. He wasnt incapacitated.
He noted no ordinance exists for dismissal. Rules clearly state you cant have alcohol on your breath, he contended. I think a fairly strict disciplinary action is in order.
Adams said hes still open to punishment imposed upon Meacham. We, indeed, will not put up with this type of action, he contended, adding that the village should adopt a zero-tolerance policy.
The policy officers handbook states that officers shouldnt have alcohol and not even a scent of alcohol, and the mayor, police chief and village board should decide the punishment, Dwyer said.
On Monday, Dwyer said, The breathalyzer test is being challenged. They used a portable breathalyzer instead of a computer breathalyzer that does a printout. Theres supposedly a question of what it actually read. I feel what it read has no significance at all.
This test was administered three hours after his arrival. If there was still a trace of alcohol, he would have to arrive with a minimum of .045. Even that doesnt mean anything to me. I think an officer understands that expectation of his job. The higher the rank, the higher the pain.
Dwyer fired Meacham in March 1999 because he learned Meacham falsified his job application. Meacham failed to mention he resigned under pressure from a position at the Marquette Police Department in 1981.
In August 1999, Dwyer terminated Meacham after finding out about allegations of sexual misconduct at Marquette.
Both times, the Rockton Village Board of Trustees reinstated Meacham.
The chief filed a lawsuit that August alleging that Dwyer humiliated him and deprived him of his civil rights. Meacham added six more defendants this spring who he believes conspired with Dwyer.
This November, the defendants, excluding Dwyer, settled. Terri Flodeen and Martha and Richard Dwyer were advised by their insurance companies to pay a nuisance fee to settle the case and avoid the cost of trial expenses. Because they lacked insurance, defendants Christine Vyborney and Gordon Merriman paid nothing. Meachams attorney dropped Louise Trull from the case this fall.
Lt. Steve Dickson is performing Meachams duties until the village board makes their ruling, . Meacham said his attorney, Margot Ely, advised him to refuse comment on the current situation.