State’s attorney won’t prosecute Harlem official

July 1, 1993

State’s attorney won’t prosecute Harlem official

By Jeff Havens, Staff Writer

n Contract amounts violate law, economic interests not revealed

The Winnebago County State’s Attorney’s office has warned the Harlem School Board if it continues to award contracts that violate either the public School Code or Public Officers Prohibited Activities Act (POPAA), it will “prosecute,” said Chuck Prorok, deputy state’s attorney. State’s Attorney Paul Logli said his office will not prosecute a fiscal year 2002 violation of the School Code because the board member in question, Mark “Duggan” Floyd, acted on advice from the board’s attorney, Rob Cooper.

Cooper, of the law firm of Ottosen Trevarthen Britz Kelly & Cooper, Ltd., which has three offices in the Chicago area, gave documents to the state’s attorney’s office in March of this year, according to Gary Kovanda, assistant state’s attorney. Kovanda said the documents prompted the review by his office, even though concerns about the contracts with Hughes Business Technologies, Inc., and Pearson Plumbing and Heating—a division of Stenstrom Companies, Ltd.—were also voiced by another school board member, Gloria Kelly. Cooper did not return telephone calls.

Kovanda said during fiscal year 2002 (July 1, 2001-June 30, 2002) Harlem contracted with Hughes for a total of $377,709. The amount violated the School Code but not the POPAA because Floyd is also an employee of Hughes. Numerous attempts to reach Floyd were unsuccessful.

In addition, Kovanda said Cooper advised Floyd and board member Michael Letsinger, who works for Pearson, that they did not have to report their economic interests on their statement to the county clerk because they were employees of the businesses, not owners. Harlem contracted with Pearson for $15,895 in fiscal year 2002, Kovanda said.

On their economic interest statements filed in March 2002, Letsinger and Floyd responded to all eight economic scenarios by writing “NA,” meaning not applicable. For example, the second scenario reads: “List the name of any entity doing business with a unit of local government in relation to which the person is required to file from which income in excess of $1,200 was derived during the preceding calendar year.”

In their 2003 statements, Letsinger and Floyd state they are employees of Pearson and Hughes for item six. Floyd wrote he abstains from voting and has “no financial interest in the company. Letsinger reports he has “zero percent ownership in the buisness, “but does not state his abstention from votes concerning Pearson contracts.

Kovanda said Letsinger and Floyd should have reported their interests but wasn’t sure if they violated the Illinois Governmental Ethics Act by not doing so. The parties agreed to disclose the information on the 2003-2004 statements, Kovanda said.

From July 2001 to March 2003, Kovanda said Harlem paid Hughes $512,844 and Pearson $21,102. As to the contracts with Pearson, Kovanda said, “The evidence [given to Kovanda by Cooper] doesn’t show a violation of the School Code or the Public Officers Prohibited Activities Act.”

Regarding the question of awarding no-bid contracts to the companies, Kovanda said that was an issue that was “not explored.” Kovanda added, “… even if there was a violation of the statutes, it’s not an issue the state’s attorney would handle because of 10 times penalties for violation are not prescribed.”

Logli said his office’s approach to potential or actual conflicts of interest is to try to work with parties, rather than pursuing punitive actions. The Harlem case is different from a Rock Valley College situation because Logli considered RVC board member and former RVC board bhairman Don Johannes an “agent rather than an employee” of a Chicago-based insurance agency.

Information about Illinois compiled statutes: http://www.legis.state.il.us/legislation/ilcs/chapterlist.html.

Information about Illinois public acts: http://www.legis.state.il.us/legislation/publicacts/default.asp

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>