Breaking News

Left Justified: How to win the war in Afghanistan

December 22, 2010

By Stanley Campbell

You can’t win the war in Afghanistan.

Now, before you turn away, please hear me out.

I thought it was extraordinary how our CIA and Defense Department allied themselves with various warlords and quickly rolled over the Taliban government. Too bad they couldn’t catch Osama bin Laden, but our leaders were already too busy eyeing Iraq.

We should have, and could have, followed former Secretary of State Colin Powell’s suggestion of taking a different, non-military tack. Our country, so wounded, yet never stronger in the eyes of the world, might have hammered together a plan to end terrorism once and for all, use economic (not military) means, setting up an international force to police the world.

Fat chance. Too bad.

Our new young black president, instead of staying in Afghanistan, should have announced we’ll capture bin Laden, then leave. Hell, the Taliban might have served Osama up to us.

And we might have been able to finally bring the troops home. But our leaders have a different idea—more war.

When in Vietnam, I heard of a plan for winning that foolish war: Round up all the natives who support the U.S., and put them on boats. Then, flatten the country, even using nuclear weapons. Then, sink the boats. A sick joke, but that was a sick war. Unfortunately, the same could be said of Afghanistan.

Yes, we could try to build up the government, or build schools all over the countryside, or have three cups of tea with every village elder. But the military can’t do that.

Our warriors can kick anybody’s butt, but they should not be expected to occupy another’s country, unless we teach our troops Pashtun (and every other language in that region), convert them all to Islam, and move their families there as well.

You want to occupy Afghanistan, Iraq and even Iran? Fine, you move there. Happy Holy Daze.

Stanley Campbell is executive director of Rockford Urban Ministries and spokesman for Rockford Peace & Justice.

From the Dec. 22-28, 2010 issue

One Comment

  1. James C. Davis

    January 10, 2011 at 8:14 am

    From the Dec. 22-28, 2010 issue
    By Stanley Campbell
    You can’t win the war in Afghanistan.

    AND WHY NOT MR. CAMPBELL?
    If it wasn’t for liberal Demon-crats like you and all the other do gooders in DC we could win a war sometimes. If the Libs didn’t tie our troops hand behind their backs & let us win most wars wouldn’t take so long.
    How can you be so naïve as to think economic means would ever win a war with these people? These people don’t have anything and never will have anything other than their beliefs to kill the infidels’. Money has appeal to these people.
    Do you remember how THE UNITED STATES won WW1 & WW2 we broke things and killed people? That is the only way to win wars.
    When the enemy hides behind women and kids and the lib’s say its wrong to kill women and kids but it ok to have our Brave Men & Women killed there is something wrong with this picture.
    Former Secretary of State Colin Powell is the proven point of the Peter Principle; A person is always promoted to one level above what he can handle.
    How can an international force be set up when the world cannot even agree there is no global warming, which I suspect you do.
    And for your little Happy Holy Daze, I thought you was a Minister, doesn’t sound to Christian to me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>